Why you should Vote NO on Measure H - LifeTime Fitness

In this November’s election, you will be asked to vote on Measure H, which would allow Lifetime Fitness to build a 30,500-square-foot commercial gym at The Farm, instead of the smaller club that voters approved in 2020. The Poway City Council has approved the ordinance, pending at least 50 percent voter approval. The ballot measure reads:

GVCA opposes the Measure for the following reasons:

Broken Promises In 2020, Poway voters approved the Farm Specific Plan (Measure P) with a clear vision for the future of their community. This plan included a smaller, community-focused fitness facility to serve local residents. Now, Life Time Fitness, a large, publicly traded company from Minnesota, is seeking to increase the size of the proposed facility to 30,500 square feet. This drastic change undermines the original spirit of the project and strays from what voters approved.

Community Needs The Life Time Fitness proposal does not align with what Poway residents were promised. The Farm was supposed to be a development that balanced residential homes with open space, providing amenities that would benefit the immediate community. Instead, Life Time Fitness aims to serve a much larger population, drawing members from neighboring cities. This regional facility was not part of the original plan, and it doesn’t reflect the community’s needs or desires.

A recent survey conducted by the GVCA asked over 4,000 households in Poway for feedback, and of the 440 respondents, more than 80% opposed this project. The community’s voice is clear—this 30,500 square foot commercial facility does not belong in our neighborhood.

Traffic and Safety Concerns – The proposed Life Time Fitness would bring up to 2,000 members, many from outside Poway, who would access the facility via Goodeve Drive, a narrow, 25 mph residential street. This road is not equipped to handle such an influx of traffic, especially with its limited infrastructure, including a single sidewalk, numerous driveways, and a nearby playground. Safety should be the top priority for our community, and the influx of traffic could pose significant safety risks for residents, especially children.

Neighborhood Impact – Building a 30,500 square-foot commercial facility in a residential neighborhood would be disruptive and harmful. The scale of the facility would create congestion, noise, and other environmental impacts, ultimately diminishing the quality of life for nearby residents. This kind of overdevelopment doesn’t fit the unique character of north Poway or the original intent of The Farm, which was to blend housing with open space, not overwhelm it with commercial activity.

Unintended Consequences – Approving Measure H could set a precedent for future large-scale developments on land zoned for Open Space Recreation. Voting No on Measure H helps protect Poway from overdevelopment and ensures that future projects stay true to the community’s original vision.

Conclusion – For the safety, character, and quality of life of our community, we urge you to Vote No on Measure H. The proposed Life Time Fitness facility is too large, too disruptive, and does not reflect the promises made to Poway residents. Let’s protect the quality of life in Poway and keep our neighborhoods safe and community-focused.

The Farm Update (Sept 2024)

This update on The Farm is based on information provided by the developer on September 23, 2024:

  • Homes – Lennar has completed construction on all homes, with only one remaining for sale.

  • The Barn & Social – These projects are currently on hold due to elevated construction costs, rising interest rates, and current lending market conditions.

  • The Club (LifeTime Fitness) – A public vote on proposed changes to the Specific Plan will be held in November. If approved, construction is expected to commence in 2025, with an opening slated for 2026.

  • Dog Park/Meadow Amphitheater – Completion is targeted for Spring 2025.

  • Butterfly Farm – Progress is ongoing, with engineering finalized and building plans to be submitted to the City of Poway by October. Construction is anticipated to begin in Spring 2025.

  • Flower Fields – Irrigation is currently underway, and planting will begin in the fall as the weather cools.

Orchard Bend/Espola Road Beautification Project

The Orchard Bend/Espola Road monument signs received a makeover thanks to the GVCA leading and funding the project with community support. The enhancements involved clearing out dead and excess plant material, refurbishing and painting the walls, refreshing the letters, adding a second set of letters, arranging rocks, and installing plants, irrigation, and lighting.

Special thanks to Diana Berti for her design expertise and commitment, Larry Ott for providing the plants, and volunteers Scott Fisher, Vanessa Springett, Anita Edmondson, Jared Wilson, and Steven Stone.

Next on the agenda

Development of monument signs for the entrance to Green Valley at Martincoit & Espola Road. The objective is to enhance and officially mark the area as Green Valley. This project will entail tasks such as sign design, obtaining approval from the City of Poway, fundraising, and construction.

GVCA Opposes the LifeTime Fitness Club proposed for The Farm in Poway

The Green Valley Civic Association (GVCA) opposes the proposed 30,500 square foot Life Time Fitness club at The Farm development in Poway. As a community leader for over 60 years, we believe this proposal does not align with the community’s long-term vision and needs. We have urged Poway City Council NOT to approve modifications to “The Farm” Specific Plan, which currently allows for a 2,953 square foot fitness club.

Why we Oppose the LifeTime Club

The significant 10x increase in the size of the proposed LifeTime club raises serious concerns, particularly regarding traffic safety. A critical issue is that Goodeve Drive, a 25mph residential street, would serve as the main access point to this commercial development. The additional traffic generated by such a large facility would pose a danger to residents, especially children playing in their yards and at the neighborhood park on Goodeve.

Moreover, our recent survey completed by over 440 local residents revealed that nearly 80% are opposed to the Life Time proposal, with 72% preferring the originally approved 3,000 square foot fitness club. Only 37% of respondents expressed any interest in seeing other proposals for the site. These numbers clearly indicate that the majority of the community does not support the Life Time Fitness plan and values maintaining the integrity of the Specific Plan.

Survey Results

We believe, a smaller, community-focused fitness club, as originally envisioned in the Specific Plan, would be far more appropriate, and beneficial for the residents of The Farm, and Poway as a whole.


City Council Hearing

The City Council of Poway will hold a meeting on Tuesday, July 16th at 7 pm at Poway City Hall, located at 13325 Civic Center Drive, Poway. The agenda includes two significant items related to LifeTime:

  1. Agenda Item 18: A public hearing on the proposed Specific Plan Amendment, Development Review, and Conditional Use Permit. This proposal is for the construction of a 30,500 square foot recreation club and accessory uses. To be effective, it requires approval by at least 50% of the voters as per “Prop FF”.

  2. Agenda Item 19: Staff’s report for consideration of placing the measure on the ballot for the General Municipal Election on November 5, 2024.

You can provide written comments to council prior to the meeting or speak at the meeting. You can also view the meeting online at Poway City Council Meetings.

President's Message - 2024

As we reflect on 2023, it's evident that a prevailing theme in our corner of Poway has been the constant hum of construction activity at the Farm development and the natural gas pipeline along Espola and Pomerado Roads. While we eagerly anticipate the day when the disruptions fade away, it's heartening to note the significant progress made this year, bringing us closer to the moment when normalcy returns to our lives. Let’s take a brief look back at some significant events from this year and share some thoughts for the upcoming year.